Open an options position and your platform shows several prices at once. They measure different things, and confusing them is why your P&L can look better (or worse) than what you can actually get.

The three numbers

Bid / Ask. The best price someone will buy from you (bid) and sell to you (ask) right now. This is what you can actually transact at — the real, tradable price.
Mark. Usually the midpoint of the bid and ask. Brokers use the mark to value your open positions, so your unrealized P&L is calculated off the mark, not off what you'd get selling into the bid.
Last. The price of the most recent actual trade. On a thin strike, the last trade could be minutes old and far from the current market — a stale number.

Your P&L is marked to the mid; your exit fills at the bid. On a wide strike, that gap is the surprise.

Why the P&L looks wrong

If your position is marked at the 1.25 mid but the bid is only 1.15, selling gives you 1.15 — a dime worse than the P&L implied, because you cross half the spread to exit. On a wide or thin strike that difference is real money. The mark is a fair-value estimate, not a guaranteed exit.

The takeaway

Trust the bid/ask for what a trade will really cost or return, treat the mark as an estimate of fair value, and be skeptical of a stale last on illiquid strikes. Trading liquid, near-the-money SPY strikes keeps all three numbers close together — which is exactly what you want when a scalp comes down to pennies.